lady_laetitia: (Cat)
[personal profile] lady_laetitia
On December 14, 2012

20 children died in school shooting - Millions of children attend school safely
More than 20 children died in car accidents - Millions of children rode vehicles safely
More than 20 children died choking on toys - Millions of children played with toys safely
More than 20 children died when furniture fell on them - Millions of children interacted with furniture safely
More than 20 children died in playground accidents - Millions of children played on playgrounds safely
More than 20 children died of food allergies - Millions of children ate safely.

Tragic as this shooting is, it must be viewed in perspective. Just as we do not try to restrict vehicle or toys or furniture or food ownership and use because a very small percentage of children die, we can not, should not, try to penalize gun owners for what is a very minor percentage of gun use. Even countries with strict gun control have had both gun massacres as well as mass killings using other weapons. It is impossible to eliminate everything a mentally ill person might use to kill others.

When I was a child, a mentally ill father walked onto a school playground during recess with dynamite and blew himself, his kid, several other kids and teachers to smithereens. Horrible? Yes. But the world did not overreact because outside of the city where it happened it was not shoved into everyone's face constantly on the news. And where it happened people put the incident in perspective - they sent their kids back to school the next day and ran some drills to remind kids to obey their teachers. No calls for turning schools into mini-jails with the kids locked in, no calls to further restrict purchases of dynamite. in other words, people reacted in an reasoned, ADULT, manner instead of hysterically overreacting.

There is NO WAY to make life 100% safe for everyone under every circumstances and attempting to eliminate everything that might, in some way, hurt someone is giving us generations of both timid fearful children and adults as well as generations of adults incapable of making responsible decisions for themselves. Just as a parent cannot protect a child 100% from ever being hurt in any way, the government cannot protect people from being hurt, nor is it the government's responsibility.

Blame for the school shooting can be laid in this order
1. The shooter
2. The shooter
3. The shooter
4. The lack of accessible mental health care for uninsured adults
5. The lack of a mechanism to treat unwilling mentally ill adults
6. The media, which sensationalizes these incidents feeding the fantasies of the mentally ill to do something bigger and badder so they will be famous.

Every time the US makes laws based in emotional reaction to some isolated incident or in an attempt to protect us from ourselves, be it 9/11, the war on drugs or this school shooting, it does nothing to prevent other incidents and does everything to penalize law abiding people and violate our human rights.

Restricting gun ownership will not end gun violence. Surprisingly enough criminals will not care if they break another law by stealing a gun (as is noted by the last two shootings where the shooter *stole* someone else's legally owned guns) nor will the mentally ill care if they break an extra law or two in route to the glorious infamous end.

Date: 2012-12-18 02:22 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] david wilford (from livejournal.com)
Here's another perspective on gun deaths that was published after the killings at Virginia Tech in 2007:

http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2007/04/21/weekinreview/20070422_MARSH_GRAPHIC.html

The U.S. does in fact have a serious problem with gun violence that we shouldn't minimize with facile analogies. Other nations that have enacted stricter gun control laws such as Australia and Canada have significantly lower death rates due to firearms and it's not hard to understand why in the aftermath of yet another mass killing by one individual using guns expressly designed to fire rapidly using ammunition made to cause deadly wounds.

Date: 2013-01-11 11:20 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ladylaetitia.livejournal.com
The Us has a real problem with hate, intolerance and the resulting violence. The lack of mental health care is also a big contributing factor to the problem. In several of the most recent shooting, the shooter broke a law to begin with by stealing guns. More laws would not have prevented it.

It does no one any good to further abridge the rights of law abiding citizens in a vain attempt to stop criminals from breaking a law.

Profile

lady_laetitia: (Default)
lady_laetitia

November 2015

S M T W T F S
1234567
891011121314
15 161718192021
22232425262728
2930     

Page Summary

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 21st, 2017 05:14 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios